Well Dweller review: this metroidvania is built on exploring

Well Dweller has no interest in reinventing the metroidvania, and it doesn’t pretend otherwise. The new game from Kyle Thompson, who also made Crypt Custodian and Islets, sticks to the most classic structure the genre has. Where it stands out is in how well everything else is made: movement with superb precision, rich exploration and a dark fairy-tale world that also knows how to make you laugh. I found the combat and bosses a notch below the rest, though that never spoils the whole thing.

At a glance

A classic metroidvania in structure, but remarkably well executed.

Exploration and movement are the heart of the experience, and they are excellent.

Expect around twelve hours, more if you are going for 100%.


A cruel fairy tale starring a tiny bird

In this dark fairy-tale kingdom, a queen has the birds slaughtered so she can use their feathers, and that tells you straight away what kind of story you’re in. You play as Glimmer, one of the last survivors, who lives with his family at the bottom of a well and sets out to find food for his sick mother.

It quickly turns into a rescue mission once Glimmer’s mother and siblings are taken. Those siblings matter a great deal to the mood, too, popping up regularly throughout the adventure and bringing loads of personality to the world.

What I liked most is the way it mixes tones. Well Dweller keeps swinging from horror and cruelty to completely absurd humour, and its most macabre moments are regularly undercut by a line of dialogue or a comic scene. It dares to go dark without ever feeling heavy.

And the art direction plays on the same contrast, with a very clean, picture-book style for the backdrops and enemies and bosses that take on far more grotesque, dark and horrific shapes. Environments change their look and mood regularly, which keeps you wanting to see what’s next.

This isn’t Kyle Thompson’s first metroidvania, either. Well Dweller’s Steam page presents it as the work of the creator of Crypt Custodian and Islets, two games in the same genre, and you can tell he knows the conventions inside out. Nothing is left to chance in the way the world opens up, how abilities are handed out, or how you’re drawn back to the areas you had to leave behind. Well Dweller is published by Top Hat Studios.


Well Dweller is a joy to explore and to move through

Exploring is clearly the heart of the game: the kingdom is huge and everything links up, so you’re constantly nudged back into areas you’ve already visited. You pick up new movement abilities that gradually open paths you couldn’t reach before, in the most faithful tradition of the genre. If that loop appeals, End of Abyss, this autumn’s other indie metroidvania, offers a far more horrific take on it.

The kingdom map of Well Dweller and its interconnected areas
The Well Dweller map, a large kingdom where every area links up with the others. Image: Kyle Thompson, Top Hat Studios.

And the movement really is great. Jumping, climbing, dashing, gliding and swinging the matchstick all flow together smoothly and precisely. Simply getting around is a pleasure in itself, and that’s probably what sets Well Dweller apart from a merely decent metroidvania.

Your matchstick earns its keep outside combat as well, since some puzzles are built around it: you use it as a spring, for instance, or to trigger a mechanism. Each biome also brings its own mechanics, with temporary platforms, bubbles, bells and other area-specific bits that keep the levels feeling fresh.

Puzzles are usually simple to understand but sometimes tricky to pull off, especially when you have to chain several movement abilities together. For me, that’s the right balance: you know what Well Dweller wants from you, and the challenge comes from your hands rather than from a baffling riddle.


Secrets everywhere and trinkets to equip

The world is packed with things to uncover: secrets, collectibles, timed challenges and optional areas tucked away all over the place, including bird spirits to free and pages that tell little stories. If you like to finish games at 100%, you’ll have plenty to do long after the credits roll.

To tweak your build a little, there are trinkets, items that grant various bonuses and are equipped according to the slots you have. Early on you don’t have many, so you’re making real choices, then you unlock more slots as you go, until you can equip almost everything by the end of the game.


Well Dweller since launch: two patches and a glowing reception

Kyle Thompson didn’t waste any time after launch. On 26 September, four days after release, a first patch dealt with the most pressing issues players had reported, including a rare risk of save corruption if you paused on the exact frame the game saved, key rebinding and Steam screenshots, both broken at launch. The same patch also slightly loosens the wall jump, according to the patch notes the developer posted on Steam.

The second patch, released on 2 October, mostly tidies up smaller bugs: trinkets that weren’t handed out for returning lost spirits (they’re now added when you load your save), a boss fight where some players got stuck, and a few spots where you could get trapped in the scenery. Two changes affect the game itself: teleporting now refills your flaming vessels, and on easy difficulty the Innkeeper chase gets checkpoints. Players are on board: as of 14 October, 98% of the 3,632 reviews on Well Dweller’s Steam page are positive, and the page also lists a Metascore of 89 for the PC version.


Simple combat and somewhat repetitive bosses

Combat is deliberately simple and takes a back seat to exploration. Glimmer mainly fights with his matchstick and a flask of flammable oil, which he can strike from a distance with the matchstick. To be fair, it’s smooth and enjoyable, thanks to effective aim assist and a dash that lets you dodge attacks.

Glimmer faces The Groundskeeper, a Well Dweller boss ringed by pink leaves
A Well Dweller boss, where the picture-book style gives way to the grotesque. Image: Kyle Thompson, Top Hat Studios.

Bosses, on the other hand, are the least convincing part: their attacks feel alike from one fight to the next and sometimes lack originality. Their difficulty is well judged, though, with no big spike to break the pace of the adventure.


Verdict: a very well crafted metroidvania

All told, Well Dweller is a particularly accomplished metroidvania that ticks every box that matters in the genre, and does it with care: excellent movement, very satisfying exploration, an original world and humour that lands. Its limits lie mainly in a structure that doesn’t innovate, and in combat and bosses that are less varied than the rest of the adventure.

Honestly, if you enjoy the genre, it’s an easy recommendation. Expect around twelve hours, more if you’re chasing 100%. The game came out on 22 September on PC, PS5, Xbox Series, Switch and Switch 2, at $19.99, and it’s on Game Pass from day one, according to Top Hat Studios’ launch press release. If you’re after a metroidvania that shakes up the formula, though, look elsewhere.

So I’d recommend Well Dweller to anyone who enjoys combing every corner of a map, backtracking with a new ability and mastering a nimble character. If you’re mainly after demanding fights and memorable bosses, you’ll find the combat side a little thin, and the indie soulslike False Hero may suit you better. And if you’re on the fence, its day-one arrival on Game Pass makes it an easy one to try for subscribers.

Hitbox verdict: Very good, between 13 and 15 out of 20

What we likeWhat we like a lot less
A cruel dark fairy tale, constantly defused by absurd humourSimple combat, pushed into the background
Picture-book art direction, contrasted by grotesque enemiesBosses with repetitive, unoriginal attacks
Puzzles and biome-specific mechanics that keep the levels fresh
Secrets everywhere, and trinkets that force real loadout choices
What might make you buy itLarge, interconnected exploration, carried by smooth and precise movementWhat might put you offA very classic structure that never reinvents the genre

Every upcoming release and update lives in our video game release calendar, refreshed at each newsroom session.