Silent Hill: Townfall review: atmosphere wins over combat

Silent Hill: Townfall doesn’t play like any other entry in the series, and that’s both its biggest strength and the thing most likely to split its audience. Screen Burn drops the over-the-shoulder camera to put you behind the character’s eyes, and builds the whole pace of the game around exploration, puzzles and stealth rather than combat. I found one of the strongest atmospheres the series has ever had, a real taste for suggestion and a handful of genuinely clever puzzles. I also found chase sequences that got on my nerves, and a production that’s clearly more modest than a big AAA release.

At a glance

First-person view, exploration, puzzles and stealth: Townfall reinterprets the series’ DNA.

The atmosphere of St. Amelia, the sound and the atmosphere it builds through suggestion are the game’s big successes.

Stealth against a near-invulnerable creature and clumsy combat are its main weaknesses.


Silent Hill: Townfall sees the series through new eyes

Screen Burn’s first big decision hits you within two minutes: the third-person camera that followed the series for years is gone, and you’re looking straight through the character’s eyes. It reshapes what the game actually asks you to do.

If you’re expecting a survival horror where you empty a clip into every corridor, I’ll say it up front: you’re in for a shock. Silent Hill: Townfall leans heavily towards exploration, stealth and puzzle-solving, and leaves fighting well behind. This is a game where you look and listen far more than you shoot.

What stands out is how consistently it all pulls together. The first-person view serves immersion, immersion serves tension, and tension serves a story that would rather be uncovered than told. Every design choice pulls in the same direction. You might not like where it’s heading, but it’s hard to accuse the game of not knowing where it wants to go.

Silent Hill: Townfall launches on 24 September on PC and PS5, co-published by Annapurna Interactive and Konami, according to Konami’s official announcement. And if you want to set this review against the first published verdicts, we rounded up how the press received it when the embargo lifted.


Watch it too

Silent Hill Townfall is betting on its own review scores

St. Amelia, a Scottish village lost in the fog

This is the thing that stays with me first: the Scottish coastal village of St. Amelia, smothered in thick fog, sets up a heavy, oppressive and deliberately mysterious atmosphere. You move slowly, because the place itself makes you want to check every corner before taking another step.

A St. Amelia monument lost in milky fog in Silent Hill: Townfall
The centre of St. Amelia, where the fog swallows anything more than a few metres away. Image: Screen Burn Interactive, Konami.

Silent Hill: Townfall takes its time, lets you look around and work out where you are, then suddenly triggers far more brutal spikes of tension. That contrast between long quiet stretches and sudden bursts of danger is what works best here.

And the first-person view strengthens the effect. Encounters with creatures feel closer and more claustrophobic, and the direction makes heavy use of cinematic framing and tight spaces. Where an external camera would let you see danger coming, Silent Hill: Townfall shoves it right in your face.

Music and effects play a direct part in the horror, and the quiet phases mostly serve to let the tension drop just before Silent Hill: Townfall puts you back in trouble. Silence is as unsettling here as noise.


Puzzles that make you actually look

Puzzles take up a lot of room, and honestly that’s good news. They regularly ask you to study your surroundings, read the clues and make the connections yourself, instead of picking up a code written in plain sight on a wall. Silent Hill: Townfall trusts the player, and rewards you when you get it right.

Several situations rely on understanding the environment, and the moment the answer clicks is genuinely satisfying. Honestly, those were the passages that hooked me most. That said, a few puzzles felt too obscure to me, and the line between well-judged difficulty and a clue you simply can’t find gets thin fast.

Searching a room is as much about understanding the story as finding what you need to survive: computers, cassette tapes, slides, documents and assorted 1990s objects gradually piece together what happened in the town. Exploration and storytelling move forward together.

The portable TV held up in a foggy street of Silent Hill: Townfall
The portable television, a detector, a receiver and the key to some puzzles. Image: Screen Burn Interactive, Konami.

The smartest idea, for me, is the portable television that replaces the series’ traditional radio. It detects creatures, picks up transmissions and plays a part in certain puzzles. It works as a storytelling device, an exploration tool and a survival tool all at once, and it ties into every side of Silent Hill: Townfall.


Direction that hints rather than explains

Time plays a central role in Silent Hill: Townfall. The game uses the idea of a loop several times and brings you back to places you’ve already visited, with shifts in context, mood or layout. Going back somewhere never quite means finding it as you left it.

And the direction would rather suggest than spell everything out. Some creatures, events and phenomena stay deliberately unexplained. The game leans on silhouettes, distant apparitions, sounds and small details in the scenery to feed the unease. Here the fear comes mostly from what the scenery lets you guess at.

To be fair, it asks for patience. If you want clear answers and a well-defined threat, you’ll find the game frustrating at times. For me, that’s exactly what gives Silent Hill: Townfall its identity, and what brings it closest to the series at its best.

For long-time fans, there’s a point worth making: Silent Hill: Townfall sets aside the conventions of the best-known entries, their camera and their approach to combat alike. What it keeps is the series’ most precious quality, that knack for making a place feel wrong before anything has even happened there. Fans who love the series for its unease more than its monsters will find plenty here, and those are the players it speaks to most directly.


Stealth and combat, the two real weak spots

Combat clearly isn’t the focus, and the game makes no secret of it. Fights stay fairly simple and can feel clumsy. Townfall pushes you to avoid, run or hide rather than clear out everything that moves, which fits its intent, but it doesn’t make the few fights any more enjoyable.

Stealth is the big change in this Silent Hill, and it’s also where the game annoyed me most. Some chase sequences become tiresome, largely because of the behaviour of a creature that’s almost impossible to hurt. Detection that feels unfair kills the fear fast. When you get spotted without understanding why, tension gives way to irritation, and the game gets the opposite of what it’s after.

The technical and budget limits show too: some environments repeat, enemy variety is limited, the overall production is more modest than a big AAA game, and a few slowdowns creep in. Still, the art direction, the fog, the settings and the realistic visuals give the game a strong identity despite its smaller means.


Verdict: an unusual Silent Hill well worth the trip

Silent Hill: Townfall bets on atmosphere, puzzles, exploration and storytelling far more than on combat. And there it gets the essentials right: St. Amelia leaves a mark, the portable television is a lovely idea, and the direction can conjure unease out of very little.

My reservations are mostly about stealth, a few puzzles that are too hard to decipher and variety that’s sometimes thin. I may be wrong about how much those flaws will weigh for you, because a lot depends on your tolerance for chase sequences. What remains is a more modest production than its predecessors, but one with real artistic coherence and a clear wish to read Silent Hill’s DNA another way.

All told, I’d recommend Silent Hill: Townfall to players who enjoy searching, reading, linking clues together and letting a mood seep in, even if it means putting up with a few tiresome stealth passages. If you’re mainly after action, tense fights and a threat you can face head-on, skip it or wait for a sale. Anywhere in between, it’ll come down to your patience with the chases, which remain the real tipping point.

Hitbox verdict: Very good, between 13 and 15 out of 20

What we likeWhat we like a lot less
Puzzles that make you study your surroundings and connect the clues yourselfSimple, clumsy combat that you mostly try to avoid
The portable television, a detector, receiver and puzzle tool in oneA few puzzles so obscure that the clue becomes impossible to find
A story pieced together through cassette tapes, slides and documentsA modest production: repeated settings, little enemy variety, a few slowdowns
Sound design and direction that build unease through suggestion
What might make you buy itThe atmosphere of St. Amelia, a Scottish village drowned in fog, heavy and oppressiveWhat might put you offChases against a near-invulnerable creature, with detection that sometimes feels unfair

Upcoming release dates and major updates are tracked in our games calendar, which you can filter by platform.